
BY DAVID DOWNS | Sept. 23 | SAN FRANCISCO—We might need beneficial propaganda to save diverse, good-feeling weed from extinction by the trap, the chads, and the cops.
That’s one of the musings from the firebrand memer, head of genetics at Highline Nursery, and breeder Nelson Lindsley (aka Poetry of Plants).
Lindsley took some time after hours to talk Toad Venom breaking the candy wave, how the industry has left behind the mainstream consumer, and more in this interview conducted before Clonetopia last weekend. Authentic Ronin Seeds Toad Venom clones from Highline Nursery are on sale this week at 7 Stars, just a few trays remain. We edited this Q&A for length.
On rebuilding the post-Prop 64 clone trade in California:
David Downs: This Clonetopia event — where I aggregate demand, set up a cool, curated supply of clones and blow them out over two days with an art party next door — fits the bill of something cool and new that people are into.
We had a good one in May, and I think we are unf-cking the clone game after Proposition 64 here in California, where things fell apart. Retailers are not gardeners, apparently.
Nelson Lindsley: It changed. Before that, it was great because a lot of the retailers were also growers. That’s what shifted, I think.
David Downs: It struck me as odd as a watcher of the space because six plants were clearly legal. There should be this massive home-grow culture, and instead the whole thing just fizzled out.
Nelson Lindsley: There was a different culture back then. The growers and cultivators were more hands-on with the retailers because you would go in to vend as the grower. Now it has become more corporate, homogenized and consolidated, which has separated the farmer from the retailer and the customer.
You don’t have the same interaction and community, at least in California. I would say that’s largely the case across the country. I’ve worked in 17 states over the last three years. There are a few outliers. Maine is an outlier. Vermont is becoming an outlier. There are pockets of New York where that’s still fairly active, even though the New York program is very dysfunctional and fragmented. It’s starting to look as if they’re not only making the same mistakes as California, but compounding them, which is incredible to see.
We’ve lost a lot of the magic along the way, so it’s going to take people like you and others to bring that together and create that forum. Hopefully, this will drive demand for broader genetics and profiles that aren’t hyperfocused on one category of genetics — or even potency, because that’s another flawed part of all this.
‘Everything has been bottlenecked’ — On fighting for diversity in cannabis:
David Downs: To your point about diversity, I think that’s a good place to start. When I looked at what’s new about fall Clonetopia, I was excited to see not a single LCG or Runtz in the lineup. With all respect to the game, I look at Booms Pharm clone menu every week and he has 14 Runtzes.
Nelson Lindsley: That’s partly because the California cultivation industry is solely reliant on the backdoor bulk market, not the retail market. Because it is so ubiquitous across the country, you tend to see that reflected at retail. Everything has been bottlenecked into a very limited offering to consumers. There has been a complete divorce between the cultivator, the retailer and the consumer. That allows the trap market to determine what gets grown.
Managing and running genetics for Highline was very challenging because I’m not happy with the current paradigm. I’m constantly pushing the nursery to take chances on things, which is risky because the business in California is hand-to-mouth. We’ve had to go through tremendous ups and downs. To me, it’s exciting that we’ve been able to navigate that, especially because Highline is from Humboldt. Third-generation farmers started it.
I had the good fortune and privilege to work with them at the beginning and then come back around on genetics and develop relationships not only with them, but with the culture in Humboldt. I came from Florida originally, transplanted to Los Angeles and got sucked into the L.A. indoor scene. I was completely envious of everyone in Northern California because of their experience and how much genetic diversity was going on there at the time.
I was always hunting for a new experience from consuming cannabis. You would develop a tolerance to one profile, then try something new and it would open a door for me personally and creatively. I could make more music, do other things that were a lot of fun or just have a totally different high from it all.
We’ve had to navigate what the bulk market needs, which is a lot of candy, and try to anticipate when that paradigm is going to shift. The candy wave has been going strong since late 2018. It’s still going strong, but the value just isn’t there. Demand is still there, but it’s so flooded that it doesn’t have the same value as something like Toad [Venom].
The novelty of Toad is tenfold because we’re getting back to something that is green weed with a totally different profile. Even though it still has hints of Z in it, it’s different from Runtz and Gelato. It still sits in a bucket next to the Gelato bucket, but it’s a step in the right direction.
I have a seed collection. I’ve been collecting seeds for more than 20 years, and preservationists have gifted me a lot of seeds. Any time we do a hunt, I try to convince everyone to devote at least 20% of the inventory to risky things. A lot of the time, those genetics don’t land on our nursery menu because the market doesn’t demand them.
We had a Glazed Apricot Gelato with a very different profile: green weed with an almost candied Trainwreck nose and a lot of nostalgia. It was a sweeter Trainwreck — not candy in the Runtz sense, but almost a sugary Trainwreck. It did really well in all markets, which was exciting for me. That was a chance, and it solidified my ability to take more chances with the nursery.
They can’t take the risk. They have to sell through their inventory. The market has been so volatile that they have to ensure that what they allocate as mother space goes toward things they’re going to sell.
I get a little space to play. A lot of the time, those genetics end up going into my brand, which is in a few states. When something does well in the brand, I can go back and show the nursery that it’s doing well in the retail market. I use the brand to prove that different, more diverse genetics will work in the market. I have to prove it before they can take the chance. That’s how dire things are. It’s cutthroat as far as what we put on the menu and allocate in inventory.
“[Toad Venom] can break the candy wave”
David Downs: One thing that became clear at May’s Clonetopia was that the LCG craze is now about pack validation. It’s safe and it moves. Everyone knows what it should look and smell like, from the bulk wholesaler to the transporter to the end customer. No one has the margin to take a flyer on anything else.
Toad is in many ways the inverse of that story right now. There’s a big dispute over what it actually is or what it should smell or look like because of its history so far. That gives it a little energy and newness.
Nelson Lindsley: That’s what needed to happen to break out. To break out of the order created around the Runtz, candy or LCG expectation, it took drama. It took a story, and then it took value. That value had to be created at a very high level and a very small scale, but at enough scale to be a bellwether so everyone started chasing it.
David Downs: The hype is there because it has the goods. It’s not unfounded.
Nelson Lindsley: Exactly. The story of Ronin navigating the chaos of the legal market and all the other markets so those guys can continue doing what they love has taken collaboration on multiple levels with multiple farms. That has been my story as well.
Whether or not people are happy about the way Toad was released, this whole situation was engineered to break out of the candy wave. I had the thought about three years ago, when I first tried Toad: “This can break the candy wave.” I kept trying to bring OG crosses back into the nursery market, and we wouldn’t sell a single one. I wanted something that could bring back nostalgia so we could move in a different direction. When I tried Toad for the first time, I thought, “This will do it.”
That was before it was as visible in the broader market, but Toad’s journey was really a six-year journey. If you have something that’s really good, it can take that long to become relevant, especially today, because people are only going to work with what has been proven.
There isn’t a lot of room to take risks because the industry has changed so much. I understand the business approach, but that approach is killing the joy, diversity and experience for the end consumer. It is going to kill the industry in many respects and further its consolidation if we don’t start taking these chances.
I got to work with Jake, Jon Cappetta and a few other guys to bring this to the nursery and help engineer it. It really was social engineering — 100% — to get this out to the people, build a new brand that’s doing fun things in the market and break out of the Runtz vibe. It took a lot of thought, time and planning, and some engineered drama, to be honest.
David Downs: Talking to breeders who are also nurseries, you detect this throughline of heartburn—They love weed and its diversity. They want to be artists who create, but they’re straightjacketed by risk aversion. It breaks their hearts.
It’s very much like covering music and artists. I remember talking to Lou Reed. He was making a tai chi drone album, and I asked, “Why are you doing this, man? You were in the Velvet Underground. You wrote ‘Heroin.’” He chewed me out: “I can’t fucking make the same thing over and over again.”
I see that same crossover between musicians and breeders. The passion that brought them to us came from wanting to be ravenous and push the terp envelope, and here they are stuck keeping the lights on.
Nelson Lindsley: California’s bulk market and Michigan’s bulk market have been dominant internationally. Oklahoma may be waning a little. The smaller state retail markets — not their trap markets — have much more room to bring genetics to market as long as they test high in THC.
If we can peel that component away and change the conversation about how we value cannabis at retail, we could open the door to incredible diversity in the licensed retail market. In my opinion, that would be the best thing for legalization.
The hash world has also kept genetic diversity alive. Things are still kicking that I didn’t think existed anymore because small, single-source hashmakers kept them going, won awards with them and preserved the lines because they wash well. There have been a few little bastions buffering against this complete genetic consolidation around what’s safe.
On the need for benevolent propaganda
David Downs: I want to implore the audience to take chances. Larry June always says, “You have to take chances. You have to risk.” But you can’t browbeat people about what they should do. You have to work with their self-interest.
Nelson Lindsley: You have to seduce them away from the mob.
David Downs: Exactly. You have to make them think, “I want to go. I want to take this chance.”
I’m trying to think through how we induce the audience to take chances. It might be: “Are you depressed by your weed, and do you have a dirty house? You should take a chance on a sativa, an effect or a flavor.” It might lead to a new friend or a new social circle. There have to be ways to market taking chances as a consumer.
Nelson Lindsley: I think that moment is arriving. Toad is an indication of it. The marketing around the campaign the Ronin guys have been doing has been excellent. It has opened doors for them in other avenues and licensed markets, which is great. They’re going to be here in New Jersey with the project I’m getting going right now.
Whatever paradigm we’ve been sitting in in California has to become fully ubiquitous before there is a moment to disrupt it. It almost needs to settle, and then we can disrupt it because people will be ready for something else.
The LCG wave carried on, and it wasn’t until everyone in the world got to try it that we could move on. That’s how big the wave was. We’ve almost had to wait for that full-circle moment. At some point, anyone who is just smoking LCG is going to get bored and want to try something else.
People say we need education. I’m going to say we need propaganda at this point because the world doesn’t respond to education. It only responds to propaganda. We need benevolent propaganda around genetic diversity. We have to make it exciting, controversial and dramatic — a story — so people pay attention.
David Downs: Positive propaganda. Make it “dropaganda.”
Nelson Lindsley: Dropaganda. Let’s coin that right now. I love it.
Read the full Nelson Lindsley Q/A in Fire Follower PRO.
Fire Follower saves you over 400 hours per year keeping up with genetics news, and you never miss a big drop. It’s for commercial breeders, growers, store buyers, PR people, executives, and pro-am aficionados. Buy this week’s issue for $25. Subscribe to 52 issues and save 30%. (I email you the full genetics intelligence report when you pay.)

Send feedback, tips, news, corrections, and clarifications to daviddownspresents@pm.me
Did someone forward this email to you? Sign up here.

